|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
Rochester Mayor Malik Evans once again used one of his favorite phrases at the latest quarterly public safety press conference while adding some words of criticism toward naysayers.

“I want to be clear, we are not satisfied, but I’m gratified that we continue to see a reduction in these (crime) numbers,” Evans said. “I will tell you that unfortunately when numbers go up, we have people that are willing to tout the numbers going in the wrong direction. (We have) lots of lots of attention, lots of calls, lots of people wanting to highlight numbers when they’re going in the wrong direction.”
“Literally, there are people who want to see numbers go in the wrong direction because they’re more concerned about negativity than positivity,” he continued. “When we talk about transparency, our goal is to put the numbers out. And unfortunately for some people that means even when the numbers are going in the right direction and these numbers are going in the right direction.”
Through the first nine months of 2026, most categories of reported crime are at record 15-year low levels. The fall in the number of robberies, larcenies, and burglaries appears to be part of a historical decline in those types of crimes, while the decrease in homicides seems more to be falling in with pre-COVID pandemic levels after experiencing a spike in 2021 and 2022.
Similarly, the 870 motor vehicle thefts reported through the third quarter is higher than the average, but is significantly lower than the 3,285 reported in 2023.
Aggravated assaults, which are violent crimes with an intent to harm, remain at elevated levels, however. A sudden rise in these cases occurred in 2020 and has yet to fully abate, unlike homicides.
The eastern side of downtown, which includes the RTS bus terminal, Parcel 5, and the Eastman Theatre, is where this increase is most apparent. Over half of the 51 violent incidents reported there so far this year were aggravated assaults as opposed to other types of violent crimes.
Evans emphasized that these incidents are connected to a worrying trend of increased domestic violence in the city as well. He announced at the press conference that a roundtable on the issue would be held during October, which is Domestic Violence Awareness month.
The eight homicide victims by firearm is a low figure, tying with 2011 for the lowest number through the third quarter of the year. The 109 non-fatal shooting victims is about the average for that measurement, representing an uptick compared to the numbers halfway through the year. They continue to be most concentrated in the North Clinton neighborhood, the historical epicenter of this type of violent crime.
Evans reiterated his resolve to keep the city’s gun violence state of emergency in place.
“People keep saying, ‘When are you going to end the state of emergency?’ I won’t end it until we get to where Japan, Singapore, and Iceland are with their shootings,” he said, citing those locations’ high populations but low gun violence rates.
“I believe that as a country we can get there, but I don’t run the country, I run the city. And my goal is to try to get us there as a city,” added Evans. “We still have a long way to go, but we have made tremendous, tremendous progress and we will continue every quarter, every month, to report on the progress that we are making in our city.”
The gun violence state of emergency was first instituted in 2022 and has been renewed on a monthly basis since then. It broadens Evans’ powers by widening the number of actions that require mayoral authorization only. These include mobilizing services from a variety of city agencies to regulate traffic, establish curfews, control pedestrian movement, and close places of amusement or individual businesses.
Over the summer, Evans presented the idea of instituting an adolescent-based curfew, which instead transformed into a late-night ban on unpermitted public gatherings of 10 or more people of any age. Permitted events, emergencies, work placements, or exercise of First Amendment rights to speech or religion are exempt from the ban. Similar to the state of emergency, it has been renewed since its introduction in July.
Corporation Counsel Patrick Beath reported that seven locations were shut down over the summer using emergency orders. He highlighted one incident at a short-term rental property on Monroe Avenue, close to Jeremiah’s Tavern, as illustrative of the actions.
“In June, we had a party at a short-term rental location that got out of control and resulted in a shooting. We contacted the short-term rental platform after that. It was immediately taken off the platform for a short period and we shut it down,” said Beath.
“Unfortunately, it was put back on the platform in August. Another party got out of control. This time, no shooting, thank goodness,” he continued. “We found out and contacted the short-term rental company. We used the emergency order. They have now permanently delisted that location from their site.”
Property crime rates are largely declining and still mostly occur near the University of Rochester, in the eastern part of downtown, or the East End entertainment district. Reports of motor vehicle related crime also continue to be near those two patrol beats.
The mayor and Rochester police chief David Smith both also congratulated Officer Nicole Amatore for being honored by Gov. Kathy Hochul as 2026 Police Officer of the Year.
Responding to a domestic disturbance on Dec. 19, 2025, officers on scene were ambushed and fired at. While three other officers were wounded in the firefight, Amatore neutralized the gunman, killing him, while under fire herself with the tree she used as cover being struck.
“Her courage and bravery saved countless lives last December, including three members of the RPD. and I could not be more proud of her or all the members of the Rochester Police Department that risk their lives every day to protect this community,” Smith said.
RPD staffing numbers, a usual talking point for the chief, were not mentioned at this press conference. He did express encouragement that over 700 people applied to take the upcoming police officer exam in October.
Zequa Tookes, director of the Office of Violence Prevention, also spoke about his department’s efforts, in particular highlighting the work of Pathways to Peace. This will be the third year the program is using a case management approach at the nine local schools it is partnered with.
“Over the past two years, we’ve seen the importance of building that strong relationship with our students, families, and our school staff. For us, that relationship is the foundation of the work that we do,” Tookes said.
Over the summer, he said, Pathways to Peace conducted 155 interventions as well as 38 home visits.
Jacob Schermerhorn is a Rochester Beacon contributing writer and data journalist.
The Beacon welcomes comments and letters from readers who adhere to our comment policy including use of their full, real name. See “Leave a Reply” below to discuss on this post. Comments of a general nature may be submitted to the Letters page by emailing [email protected].
REALLY??? Many of us can’t tell:
https://www.facebook.com/howard.j.eagle/posts/pfbid02b5kzKFQC72jPGsXU6ZzzsD8GksyhxGmjtex9CCsnSSuWBLav2P192FZsM8oNtUkal