Brighton denies discrimination in Nativity scene lawsuit

Print More
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

The town of Brighton has formally denied allegations that it discriminated against two Christian residents who sought permission to erect religious holiday displays in Twelve Corners Memorial Park.

In a 22-page response filed on Oct. 9 in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of New York, the town and Supervisor Bill Moehle deny violating the constitutional rights of Brighton residents Gennaro Polverino and Jesse Siegfried, who sued after unsuccessful efforts to obtain permission for a Christmas Nativity scene and an Easter banner, respectively.

The defendants, represented by Rochester law firm Mancuso Brightman PLLC, asked the court to dismiss the lawsuit in its entirety.

The filing marks the town’s first response to a dispute that began more than two years ago.

As the Beacon previously reported, Polverino, a physician and devout Catholic, began seeking permission in December 2023 to place a privately sponsored Nativity scene in the small park in the heart of Brighton. A Menorah often has been erected there during Hanukkah and a banner celebrating Ramadan has also been displayed.

After more than two years of unsuccessful attempts—including phone calls, emails, in-person visits and a certified letter—to get a reply to his request, Polverino filed suit in July. The complaint was amended in September to include Siegfried, a 13-year Brighton resident, who says his request to display an Easter banner was likewise ignored.

The plaintiffs, represented by the American Center for Law and Justice, a conservative Christian advocacy group, note the privately sponsored Jewish Menorah and the Muslim Ramadan banner, and claim Brighton has opened the park to private religious expression but has treated Christian displays differently from other religions. 

Alleging religious viewpoint discrimination, the plaintiffs claim violations of the First Amendment’s protections for free speech and free exercise of religion, as well as the 14th Amendment’s equal protection guarantee. 

Their complaint does not seek removal of the Menorah or Ramadan banner but asks for what it calls “neutral and even-handed treatment.” It asks Brighton to permit Polverino’s Nativity during the Christmas season and Siegfried’s Easter banner during Easter, on the same terms as other private religious displays.

In its answer, the town admits only that Brighton is a town, that Moehle is the supervisor, that Twelve Corners Memorial Park is located “at the intersections of Elmwood Avenue Monroe Avenue, and Winton Avenue,” and that private organizations have used the park in the past to “erect holiday displays” and to “engage in various forms of expression.”

The town also admits it never responded to a June 12 final demand letter sent on Polverino’s behalf before the present lawsuit was filed.

But the town denies all other allegations, including that Moehle “refused to respond to all prior requests” and that Siegfried “was ignored.” The lengthy response uses the word “deny” and its variations 156 times.

In its response, the town includes a laundry list of “affirmative defenses” to plaintiffs’ claims. These include that plaintiffs lack standing to sue, that “the alleged damages were caused by plaintiffs own conduct,” that all acts of the town were “justified and lawful” and done in “good faith,” that whatever injuries plaintiffs sustained “were caused in whole or in part … by culpable conduct … of the Plaintiffs” themselves or by someone else, that actions by the town were “viewpoint neutral” and “unrelated to Plaintiff’s viewpoint, religion, ideology, opinion, or perspective,” and that defendants “did not engage in any discriminatory conduct.”

The answer does not provide any explanation for the experiences described by the plaintiffs, nor does it set out any procedures governing applications for religious displays.

The defendants request a jury trial, dismissal of the complaint, costs and attorneys’ fees.

The central constitutional question thus remains unresolved: When a municipality permits private religious displays in a public park, what obligations does it have to accommodate requests from other religious groups?

The Beacon requested comment from plaintiffs’ attorney Abby Southerland of the American Center for Law and Justice but did not hear back by the time this article was posted.

Peter Lovenheim is Washington correspondent for the Rochester Beacon. He is author of “In the Neighborhood” and other works. His most recent book, “Gift Shop of Gratitude,” was published in 2024. He can be reached at [email protected].

The Beacon welcomes comments and letters from readers who adhere to our comment policy including use of their full, real name. See “Leave a Reply” below to discuss on this post. Comments of a general nature may be submitted to the Letters page by emailing  [email protected]

13 thoughts on “Brighton denies discrimination in Nativity scene lawsuit”

  1. I noted in an article on a completely different subject that I just submitted to the Beacon that Brighton has the largest number of zoning districts and requirement of any local town. This often indicates an environment of overcautious protection that ossifies government’s ability to respond to new challenges. It may have contributed to the lack of response the plaintiffs experienced.

  2. Outrages! What is wrong with the request? People that are come to Brighton would love to see it.They may just go to another more friendly Town to shop.

  3. The central constitutional question thus remains unresolved: When a municipality permits private religious displays in a public park, what obligations does it have to accommodate requests from other religious groups?

    Perhaps not. This supposes an underlying assumption that what the plaintiffs are alleging is true. Let’s keep in mind the plaintiffs by their own description are “devout”, have an agenda, and are presenting their best spun case.

    This is why we can’t have nice things.

    • There are only three questions here that seem relevant. 1) Has the town allowed any religious groups to use public land to promote their “product”. Clearly the answer is, yes. 2) did the plaintiffs ask for equal treatment for their religious “product”. Again, the answer is clearly, yes. That leaves the unanswered question 3) what standing does a religious group have to have to make a request? In other words must the request be made by an ordained/licensed/etc. religious official on behalf of a recognized religious organization. Or can anyone make the request based on their personal religious beliefs? Or their personal lack of religious beliefs in the case of an atheist or a group of atheists?

      • Agreed. The third is especially relevant.

        Again, an allegation is not proof. As with the Cornell incident, there is a lot of riding on a bandwagon that may be going nowhere.

        “We just don’t know enough”, is a phrase politicians and the court of public opinion needs use more frequently.

    • You mean like asking for standing?

      Do you really believe every religious zealot should be able to erect whatever they want on government property?

      God help us. /s

      • I’ve made my stand clear on religious displays on government property. The only answer should be NO to all requests. Religious displays have a home…on church property or other private property.

        I believe you totally misunderstood my original comment. It was only about government leadership no bothering to respond to citizens’ requests. Though I suppose in this case no response is a response, but everyone deserves an actual response.

    • Agreed every request, no matter how absurd, baseless, or goofy should get a response.
      Unfortunately, sometimes no response is a response, especially when dealing with zealots, activists, or nitwits who just want to argue.

  4. This is the perfect representation of how the Brighton Town Supervisor has run the Town for decades! Avoid answering ! Avoid responding! THEN deny the allegation BUT never-never answer the questions! And really Mr. Moehle – you need to spend Town money to have an attorney write 22 pages and NOT ANSWER the questions asked?
    Well fortunately for the residents of Brighton on November 3 we get the Vote in a NEW SUPERVISOR and stop the behavior we have lived with.
    Nate Salzman will not behave this way!

    • Let’s hope Salzman isn’t so naive as to let every goofy religious zealot put whatever they want on state property.

      Neither of these plaintiffs have showed standing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *