Albany bill touted as path for public power here

Print More
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Proposed state legislation could open a new pathway to public power.

Last week, downstate elected officials visited Rochester to discuss the potential for public ownership of the state’s power utilities. Speakers at the event included Sarahana Shrestha and Chi Ossé, elected officials from Hudson Valley and Brooklyn, respectively, as well as Kinra Johnson, a local advocate with Metro Justice and Rochester’s chapter of the Democratic Socialists of America, the event’s organizers. Shrestha and Ossé are Democrats who also are active with the DSA.

Shrestha, a state Assemblywoman for the 103rd District, has sponsored a bill that would let the state purchase the Central Hudson Gas and Electric Corp., which provides utilities to communities in the Hudson Valley. CHGE is currently an investor-owned utility, run by a parent company based outside of the U.S. The utility provider has voiced its concerns against the idea.

Shrestha argues the plan would be achieved by issuing bonds to buy the company, repaid by bill-paying customers. She maintains this would lower utility costs for residents. 

Advocates for public ownership of utilities also note that investor-owned utilities lack accountability and, because they are motivated by shareholder profit, may not have their customers’ best interests at heart. 

Though Shrestha’s bill, still in committee, refers solely to CHGE, advocates hope it will serve as a model for municipalities statewide to take control of their utilities. In Rochester, that could mean Rochester Gas and Electric would come under the control of the county government, following a feasibility study and a referendum. 

“There’s an actual process to this and (Shrestha) has really put a lot of thought into this fight, and it’s so possible,” said Ossé, a New York City Council member and supporter of the effort. 

“I just think that Central Hudson and RG&E are the most ripe in the state to go first,” said Shrestha. 

RG&E and Avangrid, its parent company, have long faced criticism for their rate hikes and service charges. In May, the state Department of Public Service commission granted RG&E a temporary rate hike of 2.9% for residential electric bills and 1.2% for residential gas bills. According to the regulatory agency, the temporary increase will let RG&E keep investing in grid development and safety while protecting customers from compounding rate increases caused by delayed adjustments. Meanwhile, the agency is still considering more permanent rates.

According to a 2020 study from the American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy, 29% of households in Rochester are energy-burdened, meaning that they spend more than 6% of their income on energy bills, making the city the fourth most energy-burdened in the country. That same report found that, nationally, high energy burdens tend to fall on low-income and Black and brown households.

Rochester for Energy Democracy, Metro Justice’s campaign for public ownership of the city’s utilities, contends that almost a third of the country’s 3,200 utility companies are publicly owned and have bills that are 13%-63% cheaper than investor-owned utilities. Municipalities that own their own utilities include Fairport, Churchville, and Spencerport, as well as larger cities like Los Angeles and Austin, though most public utilities serve rural areas.

In 2024, the Monroe County Legislature voted 16-13 against a proposed bill allocating $1 million for a feasibility study examining the potential to provide areas currently served by RG&E with a public utility. Before the vote, legislators heard more than three hours of public comment from supporters and opponents of the proposal. 

County legislators who opposed the bill argued that the $1 million study would strain the county budget. Steve Brew, then-leader of the Republican caucus in the Legislature, described the idea as “a fantasy.” 

What might have been a fantasy in 2024 may be gaining traction today, as affordability takes center stage for Rochester residents facing rising energy costs and a cold winter.

David Wazana is a Rochester Beacon contributing writer and a member of the Oasis Project’s second cohort. 

The Beacon welcomes comments and letters from readers who adhere to our comment policy including use of their full, real name. See “Leave a Reply” below to discuss on this post. Comments of a general nature may be submitted to the Letters page by emailing [email protected].

2 thoughts on “Albany bill touted as path for public power here”

  1. While I’m new to the discussion of a public takeover of RG&E, it seems that further study of the possibility would be a good thing. Rates are going up and ownership by a foreign company seem to be good reasons to conduct an affordable feasibility study. Let’s not kill the idea.

  2. …as long as any takeover includes indictment, trials and long incarceration for the board and senior executives of RG&E and their shill, Morelle Junior.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *