The real root causes of student absenteeism

Print More
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Geoff Rosenberger and Rick Dollinger refer to The Children’s Agenda’s recent report on chronic absenteeism in Monroe County and graciously add a link to our report in their Beacon “Counterpoint” article of Nov. 2.  We hope that everyone clicks on that link and reads our findings and recommendations.

The Children’s Agenda titled our report “Beyond Attendance Awareness” to highlight the fact that the major barriers to improving regular attendance aren’t some misunderstanding by parents or children about the importance of regular school attendance. Instead, families increasingly confront concrete system failures of untreated physical and mental health, persistent poverty, erratic and unavailable school transportation and family child care arrangements, and overreliance on exclusionary discipline. These problems have markedly intensified in recent years, and they plainly won’t be addressed, as Rosenberger and Dollinger hypothesize, by a “cultural reset” to restore “shame,” “personal responsibility,” “stigma” or “peer pressure” to the issue of chronic absenteeism. 

Larry Marx

The suggestion that prominent community leaders “(tell) families to get their children to school” can’t hurt. But it is as ill-targeted a solution to the actual causes of the problem as is any broad marketing to “Strive for Five” or, more simply, to “Make Attendance Great Again.”  Communication efforts such as those maywork at the margins of brief, intermittent absences, but they do not address root causes of chronic absence. It’s far too easy for our education, health care, and social service systems to slip out of their responsibility by blaming parents rather than addressing their own failures. But blaming parents and students alone for chronic absenteeism, as our report shows, defines the problem in the wrong way, leading to failed (and continuingly failing) solutions. That’s precisely why our report recommends “invest(ing) in preventative approaches to absenteeism that expand beyond traditional awareness campaigns and address root causes.”

The data in The Children’s Agenda’s report is clear: chronic absenteeism is plaguing schools throughout the country, New York State, our region and Monroe County. Rates of chronic absenteeism were on the rise nationally pre-COVID. But since then, we seem to be at a disturbing “new normal” of unacceptably high rates. The numbers are especially alarming but in no way unique to the Rochester City School District. 

So, what’s an accurate understanding of the causes of chronic absenteeism? If you follow the evidence and listen to the parents and students as we have, including the more than 300 high school students who self-reported reasons for missing school (here, page 18), you’ll see that illness is the number one reason cited.  That’s followed by:

■ family emergencies (a catch-all category that mostly indicates how precarious RCSD families’ lives are, including child care arrangements where older students are held back to care for younger children);

■ transportation issues (“thousands of [RCSD] students were affected by late buses each month in the 2023-24 school year,” often marked absent for attendance),

■ student mental health issues; and

■ suspensions (9,136 Monroe County students were suspended in the 2024-2025 school year, losing a total of 67,291 total days of education).  

Rosenberger and Dollinger float the idea of tying the issue of repeatedly missing school to families’ health care access, conjecturing that the threat or actual loss of coverage would force better attendance. One presumes they mean Medicaid, which is about to become far less available for families anyway under new work requirements designed to threaten the loss of coverage as a cudgel for employment. But in the case of chronic absenteeism, using the threat or actual loss of health care to enforce better attendance would only exacerbate the major systemic cause of chronic absenteeism, as demonstrated by our report, which is debilitating, untreated physical and mental illness.  

So, what works? What does the evidence support that actually helps reduce chronic absenteeism—especially in those schools where a high percentage of students live in poverty? Community schools are one answer. The Greece Central School District has leaned heavily on a comprehensive model, where education is combined with in-school social services, physical and mental health care, and youth development to support the whole family and the whole child.  Our report shows “the Greece Central School District is a bright spot, reducing chronic absenteeism at elementary schools to only 2.2 percentage points above pre-pandemic levels. Longridge Elementary in Greece reduced its chronic absenteeism below pre-pandemic levels from 18.5% in 2017-2018 to 6.4% in 2024-2025.” Instead of penalizing families’ health care, or shaming parents and students, regular attendance can be revived by schools having a nurse, social workers, and counselors on-site, along with enriching before- and after-school programs, available to all students and families.

The other solutions outlined in our report address the systemic barriers that prevent regular attendance, such as passing the Solutions Not Suspensions bill to stop districts’ over-reliance on exclusionary discipline except in the most extreme circumstances; improving access to affordable, quality child care that meets the needs of all household members; and improving on-time performance of buses picking up and dropping off students, while adding as many transportation options as possible.

Rosenberger and Dollinger should be applauded for recognizing chronic absenteeism as a community crisis. Dollinger is absolutely right pointing out that Child Protective Services involvement is more harmful than helpful. “Education neglect” is defined primarily as chronic absenteeism rather than child maltreatment, but intrusive investigations for education neglect more often than not harm and even separate families for the crime of poverty, rather than address the reasons why children miss school.

But if you care about academic performance, if you care about physical and mental health, and if you plainly just care about families struggling to raise children in this day and age, then you need to care about the issue of chronic absenteeism. Frankly, our report only scratches the surface. Chronic absenteeism is just the most visible layer over deeper system failures that families increasingly confront every day.  We need to work with families to advocate for evidence-based solutions to those concrete system failures, instead of blaming them for the burdens they carry.

Larry Marx is CEO of The Children’s Agenda.

The Beacon welcomes comments and letters from readers who adhere to our comment policy including use of their full, real name. See “Leave a Reply” below to discuss on this post. Comments of a general nature may be submitted to the Letters page by emailing [email protected].

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *