|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
As overdose-related deaths continue to fall, some Rochester harm-reduction advocates are examining the viability of an overdose prevention center. They say an OPC may be the next step in the fight against the city’s drug problem.
Data released in September by Monroe County’s Department of Health counted 243 overdose deaths in 2025, of which 135 were opioid-related—a 53% decrease in deaths from 2023, the peak of the nationwide opioid epidemic.
“Fewer overdose deaths means fewer families receiving devastating news. That is progress, but
243 deaths are still far too many,” said Monroe County Executive Adam Bello in a release announcing the data. “We have made naloxone and test strips easier to get, expanded street outreach and helped people connect with treatment. We will keep working with our community partners to reach people and make sure help is there when they need it.”
Overdose prevention centers, sometimes called supervised injection sites, are medical facilities where drug users are provided with sterile drug use equipment, medical assistance, and spaces to consume narcotics purchased elsewhere.
Though controversial, advocates—many of whom have experienced active addiction—argue that the facilities would reduce overdose deaths, calls to emergency services, and public drug use, while offering an avenue for active drug users to connect with services to assist them in recovery.
“We see firsthand how much of a difference it makes when people have somewhere to turn, someone who cares, and access to support without judgment. An overdose prevention center builds on that same idea,” says Gary Harding, co-founder of Recovery All Ways, a harm-reduction organization in the North Clinton area. “It provides a supervised indoor space where someone can respond to an overdose, where people can connect with health care and treatment, and where relationships can begin to develop that might not happen otherwise.”
A 2020 study by the New England Journal of Medicine on an unsanctioned overdose prevention site opened by local organizers in an unidentified American city counted 10,514 injections and 33 opioid-related overdoses at the site (each reversed by staff administering Narcan) in the five years after it opened in 2014. “Although this evaluation was limited to one city and one site that is unsanctioned, and therefore the findings cannot be generalized, our results suggest that implementing sanctioned safe consumption sites in the United States could reduce mortality from opioid-involved overdose,” the study states.
Though the site is a unique example, with trained staff and sterile facilities, a separate study’s description of the site’s operations indicates the importance of word-of-mouth, judicious assessments of immediate needs, and a low-barrier model of care in meeting the needs of users. The space is used by invitation only, the study found, and the total number of people with active privileges is fewer than 60.
“The agency provides other social services that are open to the general public. Once a person comes to the agency a few times, and appears to need supervised injection services, they are invited to use the supervised injection room. There are no formal exclusion criteria,” states the second study, published in the American Journal of Preventive Medicine.

Currently, the city works with private organizations to provide more traditional means of support for Rochesterians struggling with chronic homelessness and active addiction, two distinct but often overlapping challenges.
Efforts like the Neighborhood Ambassador Program, where the city works with community organizations to recruit ambassadors to engage at-risk community members, have expanded the city’s harm-reduction footprint and are supplemented by Monroe County’s human services and welfare programs. In February, looking to build on the success of the city/county strategy, workers from RAW, as well as City Councilmember Mary Lupien, visited an OPC in Providence, RI. Workers at RAW also visited OnePoint, a similar facility in Harlem around the same time.
State Sen. Jeremy Cooney also visited OnePoint in 2023. In an op-ed following that visit, he wrote: “What I found was a clean, professional environment. It felt like I had stepped into an outpatient hospital setting, one that had built a strong congregate community. Users and staff have developed intimate, trusting relationships. Users support each other by celebrating milestones and overcoming hardships, all while knowing the staff truly believes in the values of acceptance without judgment. OnePoint is not an unruly or isolating facility for users—it is a safe haven.”
Though OPCs tend to raise eyebrows for their safe injection and smoking rooms, Harding stresses that the facilities offer a wide range of services to those facing active addiction.
“The one we visited in New York City does have a pharmacy,” he says. “They have full-size medical rooms for doctors and nurses to see patients.”
He estimates that drug consumption takes place in only a small percentage of the facility.
Harding thinks an OPC has the potential to fill gaps in existing services for those in need, particularly at the county level, which, he argues, is set up to assist only a particular type of addict or unhoused person. For example, some active drug users have limited access to transportation, no fixed address, or valid identification—all potential barriers to receiving assistance.
“In my opinion, the staff at those places have expectations placed on them. They have job requirements that they need to meet. And that only serves a cookie-cutter population. The ones that are going to be able to make and take phone calls, that are going to be able to receive mail, that are going to have no issues with transportation,” observes Harding, citing services offered by the county’s Department of Social Services.
For those whose needs are not being met by those services, an OPC could be a more accessible option. Active drug users seeking a safe environment for drug consumption and a respite from the day-to-day challenges of addiction could be offered other support services and medical care, and potentially a path to recovery.
“(OPCs are) built to serve that population. They’re not going to be rushed. They’re going to be able to take more time with each individual person, help them really find the services that are going to be the most beneficial,” says Harding.
“Being built around harm reduction, they’re able to serve folks who may not have a desire to quit using drugs yet,” he adds. “Harm reduction could be something as simple as changing from injecting drugs to smoking drugs. Now, obviously, they’re still using drugs, but if someone’s able to start smoking a drug as opposed to injecting, they could have their wounds clear up. … Something as simple as that has shown folks like, ‘OK, I started smoking instead of injecting. My arms and legs have cleared up. What, what else can I do?’ And it starts people on a path of recovery.”
Still, offering a space for active users to consume drugs tends to be the focus of controversy. Skeptics say the facilities enable open-air drug markets to form in their vicinity, bring crime to surrounding neighborhoods, and encourage drug use. For neighborhood residents who have long dealt with the impact of on-the-street drug use, the prospect of an OPC may not seem like a solution.
“You have neighborhoods that have been historically marginalized that are expected to bear the burdens of everyone. … So (North Clinton) is a neighborhood that has (had) significant challenges over decades, has had the drug problem, drug sales, drug use for decades. And oftentimes the residents who live there are so frustrated, sometimes angry, sometimes annoyed,” says City Council president Miguel Meléndez, who has ties to the neighborhood and is involved in homeless-related issues.
“I think that the frustration isn’t that people are frustrated with people that are struggling with addiction,” he adds. “The frustration is everything that comes with it, right? All the other ancillary things that are problems on the side of it. I think most residents want people to get the help they need. They want them to get the support that they need.”
While he shares those community concerns, as well as some related to the logistical hurdles of constructing a site, Meléndez says he’s “not completely shutting the door,” and plans on visiting an OPC in New York City. He argues that the best location for an OPC would be on a medical campus, where residential communities would be less impacted by the site.
“My biggest challenge out of the gate is making sure I understand where they would be tolerated from a community perspective,” Meléndez says. “I know that many people in the neighborhood don’t want to co-locate something like an OPC with the challenges they currently face. They can’t bear the burden of all the problems. In my opinion, based on what I’ve heard of other places, they’ve been a challenge in residential neighborhoods. … And the best model that I’ve heard seems to be when it’s on a medical campus.”
The OPC visited by Recovery All Ways was in Rhode Island, where state legislation provides a framework for such facilities, as long as they have municipal approval. The city of Providence approved it as an extension of services offered by a local addiction treatment center. The facility is located next to the Rhode Island Hospital Campus.
The success of that facility, as well as others like OnePoint in New York City, is cited by advocates like Harding in their push for a facility in Rochester, and often contradicts some of the primary concerns raised by skeptics, like crime or impact on business.
One 2023 study examining the impact of two facilities in New York City found no significant increase in crime reports or calls to emergency services. A separate study from February examining the same two centers also found “no significant changes in foot traffic and consumer spending” in the neighborhoods where the OPCs are located.
Still, other studies on the impact of OPCs have shown the facilities are just one piece of the puzzle. The success of an OPC is especially reliant on the facility’s accessibility and ability to meet the specific needs of active drug users.
In a city like Rochester, that means that an OPC would have to be integrated into a larger system of services for those suffering from active addiction and related issues, like homelessness. Currently, private organizations like RAW, as well as programs like the Neighborhood Ambassador program and the Person in Crisis team work to meet those people where they are, but integrating a facility like an OPC has additional challenges, including geography.
A study published this year, which considered Monroe County as a case study on the potential benefits of an OPC, found “the distribution of overdose deaths outside the urban core highlights potential gaps in reach, particularly in suburban and rural areas. In this context, OPC implementation in Monroe County would likely require careful consideration of geographic need and accessibility, with potential value in complementing existing services by engaging populations not consistently reached through current approaches.”
Disagreements among private organizations dedicated to serving those struggling with active addiction and chronic homelessness, as well as bureaucratic red tape, particularly at the county level where social services are administered, also limit the idea of an OPC.
“I think there’s a huge need for the community to be coordinated,” says Meléndez. “What I mean by that is when I think of all the different outreach programs that are touching either addiction or trying to reach our unhoused neighbors, one organization doesn’t necessarily know what the other organization is doing. I think there’s a lot of people stepping over each other or undoing each other’s work because there’s not connection, there’s not communication.”
City Council’s 2026 Homelessness Report, released in February, calls on the city to declare a homelessness crisis. The report recommends steps to be taken to ensure greater coordination between the disparate network of city, county, and private services serving the homeless population and, by extension, many of those dealing with active addiction.
Meléndez says showing that kind coordination and planning for the long term is a prerequisite for rallying communities to support their more vulnerable neighbors, even as frustrations pile up.
“I don’t think the community understands what is happening or not happening when it comes to all these outreach teams that are doing work in the community,” he says. “Well-intended people, great hearts, some people are just donating food and doing all these other things to keep people healthy and alive. But in the same breath, what’s the end game? That’s where the community needs to understand the overall plan and the vision and the mission.”
David Wazana is a Rochester Beacon contributing writer and a member of the Oasis Project’s second cohort.
The Beacon welcomes comments and letters from readers who adhere to our comment policy including use of their full, real name. See “Leave a Reply” below to discuss on this post. Comments of a general nature may be submitted to the Letters page by emailing [email protected].