|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
Having determined that proposed changes at the downtown Kenneth B. Keating Federal Building could impact the structure’s historic character, federal officials are now asking the state to discuss ways to “avoid, minimize, or mitigate potential adverse effects.”
While the federal concerns are relatively minor—four new windows at the front of the Federal Building could alter the “historic appearance,” they say—the continuing discussions between federal and state officials show that the controversial proposal may not be resolved soon.
The state, responding to federal officials, has asked for significantly more information about the proposal.
“The New York State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) is reviewing documentation submitted by the U.S. General Services Administration (GSA) related to the potential effects to a historic property, the Kenneth B. Keating Federal Building, that would occur under its proposals to renovate and harden spaces within the building,” SHPO officials wrote in an email Tuesday.
“SHPO’s review remains open pending a response to a request for additional information from the federal government.”

Records obtained via the state’s Freedom of Information Law show that Customs and Border Protection, which wants to move its Rochester-area operation to the Federal Building, determined earlier this year that the proposal would have no “adverse effect” on the facility or its inclusion in the downtown historic district.
However, GSA, which manages federal buildings, stepped in and decided otherwise.
Earlier this year, federal officials proposed adding a small-scale detention center at the Federal Building, a proposal that officials said was first made more than five years ago. CBP would also move its Rochester office, now located in Irondequoit, to the downtown site.
However, the new plans were distinctly different in that the proposal called for three holding cells that could keep detainees overnight and for multiple days.
(WXXI News first reported the plans. A few days later I reported here about the changes in the proposal from the earlier version.)
Likelihood of ‘adverse effects’
In a July 28 letter to the SHPO, GSA officials detailed some of the physical plans for the Federal Building and asked the state to discuss how best to address possible adverse effects—a term for actions that could harm the historical integrity of a structure.
In that letter, GSA said it plans to consult with several preservation organizations, including the federal Advisory Council on Historic Preservation, the Preservation League of New York State, and Historic Albany Foundation.
“We note that GSA states in its July 28, 2026 letter that it will be consulting with the Albany Historic Resources Commission and the Historic Albany Foundation,” SHPO responded in August.
“The SHPO recommends that GSA consult with local consulting parties, including but not necessarily limited to the City of Rochester, Monroe County, and the Landmark Society of Western New York, Inc. Albany is over 200 miles from the Keating Federal Building, so the Albany-based parties identified by GSA would not be local consulting parties in this context.”
The city of Rochester has already raised multiple issues with the proposal, contending that the plans as a whole run contrary to historic preservation.
The Federal Building is located in the state and federally designated Four Corners—Genesee Crossroads Historic District, chosen for the designation because of its blend of past and more current architecture.
(More on the city’s opposition can be found in this earlier Beacon article: “Plan for immigration detention cells at Federal Building on hold.”)
In its July letter, GSA maintains that the proposal “will not impact the (district’s) significance and eligibility for listing in the National Register, but it does have the potential to affect the historic fabric of an individual contributor” to the historic district, namely the Federal Building itself.
I checked Tuesday with the Landmark Society—one of those the state said GSA should contact about the proposal—and there has been no contact yet.
The state also has asked for more information, specifically photos and higher-resolution designs, of the current interior and future plans.
The state also wants to know the responses GSA receives from its local outreach to governments, preservation agencies, and indigenous tribes. GSA indicated it would ask Native American tribes and organizations “if any attach significance” to the proposal or would want to be involved in the discussions.
Should GSA and the state not agree on the likelihood of adverse effects, there is an administrative resolution pathway to try to tackle the disagreements. There also is the possibility of litigation.
One thing is clear: The outcome of the federal plan is likely months away.
Gary Craig is a Rochester Beacon contributing writer. A retired Democrat and Chronicle reporter, he now writes on Substack.
The Beacon welcomes comments and letters from readers who adhere to our comment policy including the use of their full, real name. See “Leave a Reply” below to discuss on this post. Comments of a general nature may be submitted to the Letters page by emailing [email protected]