|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
The Census Bureau’s latest data shows an aging population, especially in the city. The Beacon’s Counterpoint columnists—liberal Rick Dollinger and conservative Geoff Rosenberger—discuss what this could mean for the region.

GEOFF: Rick, so it turns out, you and I aren’t the only ones getting older. On Oct. 29 the Census Bureau released its latest population updates and the Bureau estimates that last year the median age across Monroe County was 39.8 years. Back in 1970, the Census Bureau pegged Monroe County’s median age at 28.1 years. Which means that over the course of those intervening 55 years, every month, Monroe County’s median age has gone up by nearly a week! Which isn’t much different than the USA as a whole. But, over that half century, Monroe County’s population has stagnated, growing a mere 5% or less than 0.1% compounded annually. Meanwhile, the USA’s population has surged 73%.
When you peel back the layers of this onion, the math becomes even more troubling. Since 1970, the median age in the city of Rochester has increased by just 6.4 years, from 28.7 to 34.1 years. But in Monroe County’s suburbs the median age is now 14 years higher, more than twice the city’s increase, moving from a 28-year 1970 median to a 42-year median today. That would be little more than a point of curiosity were it not for fact that the city vs. suburban median household income differential weren’t so wide:
So, the county’s suburban residents, who shoulder the bulk of the income and property tax burden, are aging the fastest. That isn’t the formula for fame and fortune. Any thoughts?


RICK: Eghads!
Geoff—your cruelty knows no bounds—how dare you accuse this baby boomer of getting old? What gave you that idea? I walk a little slower, I struggle to remember names of my grandchildren and, yes, my fingers ache when I depress the keys of this Counterpoint and I cannot sing along with any Taylor Swift song, but I know all the words to “You Ain’t Nothin’ but a Hound Dog.”
So what?
I get it: The boomers are going bust. That universally fatal disease—age—is taking over the once vibrant boomers, who drove America’s prosperity for half a century.
I am going to play in your backyard for a minute: Adam Smith—no, despite your thoughts about your older colleague, he was not a classmate of mine in high school—was the champion of the economics of supply and demand. Create more demand and the response will be more supply.
Baby boomers created demand in America after World War II. Optimism flourished. Large families boomed—I have seven siblings. The baby boom demand launched America’s economy into the stratosphere—more homes, more cars, more education, more gadgets, more technology, better health care, more and better science, more wealth, all of which have allowed our lifespans to expand beyond anyone’s imagination at the dawn of the last century.
Now, the demand follows the boomers: more nursing home beds, more reading glasses, more slip-on shoes, more pills for aches and pains and more hearing aids.
What happens to “demand” as “da man” ages? The answer to that $64,000 question—I remember the show in the 1950s—is take a look at Japan. To use another baby boomer 1990s Seinfeld metaphor, think “shrinkage.”
GEOFF: Yeah, demographics shape the economy. No question about that. But the scary thing is that the trend appears to be accelerating locally. Look at the birth trend in each of our local school districts, which you can track here. In 2023, the most recent year for which data is available, there were 19% fewer babies born within the Rochester City School District than in 2018 and 29% fewer than in 2013. In Greece, births fell 10% between 2018 and 2023 and declined 16% versus 2013. The Penfield School District wasn’t quite as bad, down 8% and 11%.


It looks like we’re going to solve the teacher shortage—by shrinking the number of children who need to be taught! School building closures will be coming to a neighborhood near you.
The ramifications go way beyond education. As you correctly point out, an aging population places increasing demands on an already stressed health care industry. The elderly have different housing needs than young families. Their leisure time choices differ as well. There aren’t a lot of 80 year olds bombing down the slopes at Bristol Mountain.
But the real problem is financial. Again looking at Census Bureau data, 25 years ago there were 4.5 Monroe County residents aged 20 to 64 (430,311) working to support every retired resident aged 65 and over (95,699). Yes, I recognize that many people work past age 65, but there are also many people under 65 who aren’t working at all. Today, that active working-age population (424,038) to retirement-aged population (158,881) ratio is just 2.7:1 locally. And, given that there are around 5,600 more Monroe County residents aged 55 to 64 who are nearing retirement than there are children aged 10 to 19 who will be entering the workforce, that ratio is likely to deteriorate further over the course of the next decade. Fewer and fewer workers are being asked to shoulder the burden of supporting our community. No wonder voters are restless!
RICK: We are just part of the great demographic hollowing out of America.
Look at Western New York. I do not have good data but I’ll bet—you know I hate betting as evidenced by one of our last Counterpoints—I would still bet that a number of Southern Tier counties (Steuben, Yates, Alleghany) are in even worse shape with aging populations.
The same is true throughout the country: While some aging populations head south—Florida etc.—that only staves off the country’s overall demographic decline, and it eventually leads to an overload of the southern states’ long-term care and health care costs.
The falling birth rate augurs ill for the entire country, much less right here in Monroe County. I mentioned Japan earlier. I recently read that if Japan’s birthrate continues to remain static, 20% of Japanese homes will be unoccupied in 25 years. That’s catastrophic for the housing industry in any nation, especially when a large chunk of everybody’s capital is tied up in the value of a home. What about the demand for cars, other goods? As demand slips, prices slip, stagflation follows?
The trend is not only in Japan—the Scandinavian countries face the same challenge.
If the economic pie shrinks from reduced demand, do political tensions rise? Do we redefine the “American Dream?”
Is the solution more immigrants? It was once upon a time and it worked, as best as I can tell. Will it work again even right here in Monroe County?
GEOFF: Well, you’re right about some of our sister counties. The median age in Wayne County is 45.4 years. In Niagara and Orleans Counties, it’s 43.5. But being the least bad of a demographically challenged bunch is pretty faint praise. When more people die in your county each year than are born, you’ve got a problem. And, according to the state Department of Health’s Vital Statistics data, that was the case every year from 2020 to 2023 in Monroe, Erie, Onondaga and Niagara counties along with many other upstate counties as well. Clearly COVID-19 played a role. But, even if we go back pre-COVID to 2018 and look at the six-year averages, Monroe and Onondaga counties barely make it into the plus column in terms of births versus deaths, while Erie and Niagara counties remain upside down.
Rick Dollinger is a retired Court of Claims judge and a former state senator who lives in Brighton. Geoff Rosenberger is retired co-founder of Clover Capital Management Inc.
The Beacon welcomes comments and letters from readers who adhere to our comment policy including use of their full, real name. See “Leave a Reply” below to discuss on this post. Comments of a general nature may be submitted to the Letters page by emailing [email protected].