|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|

In late July, the U.S. Department of Agriculture accepted a request from Gov. Kathy Hochul to designate disaster aid for farmers whose crops were damaged by adverse weather conditions in the spring.
“New York’s growers are second to none and many have taken a significant hit, with some reporting upwards of a 100% loss of their crop and millions in economic loss,” Hochul stated in her request to the USDA.
“This hardship,” she added, “follows a trend we are becoming all too familiar with—temperature swings that are indicative of our changing climate.”
But any farmer will tell you this: It’s not the only trend threatening their livelihood. Rising costs, flat market prices, labor shortages driven in part by stricter immigration enforcement—all are squeezing operations at farms in the Rochester region.
“If you have a year where you get a hailstorm that wipes out two-thirds of your farm, guess what? Climate change is the most important thing,” says Craig Kahlke, team leader at the Lake Ontario Fruit Program, which covers over 30,000 acres of apple crops within a five-county area across Western New York.
However, he adds, “it’s more prices and returns that are starting to push growers out of business at the moment than it is climate change, but that certainly doesn’t help.”
A hard business
The Finger Lakes region is far and away is the state’s biggest agricultural earner. According to the 2024 Comptroller Agriculture Report, the region brought in about $2.34 billion, leading the state in agricultural sales. The Finger Lakes region has almost half of the state’s total farmland, the state’s highest concentration of wineries, and the bulk of the state’s apple production.
A growing number of area farmers are finding it increasingly difficult to stay in business, however.

Running a farm is hard work and the burden of overhead costs comes with it. With labor, equipment, management, fertilizer, pesticides and other expenses, there isn’t much room for profit. Most farmers are asset-rich and cash-poor; they can’t access their wealth easily. Typically, profits—if they have any—go right back into operations for general upkeep and for the next season.
The average crop farm spent a little over $250,000 in 2024, according to the USDA’s National Agricultural Statistic Service. Profit margins typically are thin. This has always been the case to some degree, but operating costs have been steadily rising for decades, while revenues have not kept pace, farmers say. Recent economic pressures have only made things worse.
The lasting effects of the COVID-19 pandemic and more recently the conflict in Iran have skyrocketed fertilizer and fuel prices. Crop prices have not followed that trend, with the gap between prices received and paid widening since mid-2023. Many farmers say they’ve had years where they’ve failed to break even.
“Most growers across the board, even field crop, field seed, processing, vegetables, they’re all not making money,” says Stephanie Craft of G&S Orchards in Walworth. “They’re dipping into their reserves in order to farm.”
Kendra Burnap, a generational farmer who operates Burnap’s Farm Market & Cafe in Sodus, echoes Craft.

“My father started this farm 40 years ago,” says Burnap. “He was getting 11 cents a pound from Mott’s for (processing) apples. They just came out with their price at 17 cents a pound this year. That’s 6 cents above where it was 40 years ago, yet the cost to grow those apples has increased 20-fold.
“The bottom line for farmers is getting smaller and smaller,” she adds.
The challenge is particularly acute among apple growers, one of the region’s and the state’s staple crops.
“The apple market is the most difficult to get prices that farmers can survive with,” Burnap says.
This is true, in part, because many farmers lack control over their own pricing.
“If you don’t sell directly to the consumer, you can’t control your pricing; that’s dictated by the buyers, retail chains and brokers,” Craft says.
This means farmers can’t pass increases in operating costs on to consumers the same way most businesses can.
“The cost of fuel and fertilizer has gone up, but we can’t pass that increase on to our buyers because it’s a top-end dictation,” Craft says.
This is unsustainable for many growers, particularly small, family operations. What’s more, many farmers have no one to take over their business; their kids have seen the struggle their parents have gone through and want no part of it.
“The numbers don’t work anymore,” Burnap says.
Adds Craft: “Some growers are just like, why bother, you know? ‘I’m at X age, and why should I keep going? If my land is worth X, I might as well sell.’ … A lot of people don’t want to work this hard and lose money every day.”
The climate factor
Along with farmers’ other troubles, climate is an increasing concern. This year marks the fourth in a row in which erratic weather patterns have plagued growers in the Rochester area and across the state.
The USDA aid designation covers five extreme weather events from March 31 to May 14. Frost was, as usual, the most common event, accounting for three of the five cited. However, this spring also brought heavy rain, flooding, wind and hail. The federal designation allows farmers in affected counties to tap Farm Service Agency programs like emergency loans, as well as other forms of subsidized relief to alleviate crop loss caused by the extreme weather events.
According to Hochul’s request, the events caused more than $30 million in total damages to farms growing apples, stone fruit like peaches and cherries, grapes, and strawberries, though the impact on individual operations varied widely.
Damages are based on several factors specific to a farm’s location—no two areas are hit the same, even if they’re geographically close, experts say.
Craft reported significant damage to her cherry crop as well as her apple and strawberry crops.
“The apple crop across the whole Northeast is down,” she says.
By contrast, Burnap says her crop was largely unaffected this year, although it did sustain significant damage in 2023.
Climate-related events are hard to predict. Historically, farmers have relied on extensive weather and climate data, as well as metrics like growing degree days, to understand how a year might go and use that data to inform what they need to focus on that season. But with changing climate and weather conditions, it can be nearly impossible to predict some events before they’ve already done damage.
In 2023, frost devastated some New York growers’ crops; in 2024, hail shredded others’ crops, and in 2025 drought affected still others. The same farms haven’t necessarily been hit by each of these events year, but for those that have been hit multiple times, it can spell financial disaster.
The last year catastrophic losses were sustained was 2012, when frost decimated large swathes of acreage and slashed total state crop yields in half.
Need to adapt
The number of farms nationwide has been declining for nearly a century. Over the last three decades, many generational farmers have been squeezed out of the industry, forcing them to sell their land to larger operations, real estate developers, or private equity firms, consolidating agricultural production.
Farmers who have managed to stay in business have done so by adapting. One strategy is diversifying crops. Another is agritainment, offering recreational and educational activities on their property for the public. Some farmers have reduced reliance on processors and distributors, turning to farm stands, Community Supported Agriculture programs, and U-pick, where consumers pick their own produce at a farm.
Since the 1980s, G&S Orchards diversified its operation from only growing apples for processing. U-pick, CSA, a farm stand and farmers’ markets—all of these help reduce the farm’s reliance on middlemen.
“Any grower that is not selling directly to a consumer has to dip into their equity, whether it’s borrowing money or using money they’ve set aside,” Craft says.

Likewise, when Burnap took over her farm from her parents 29 years ago, it was solely an apple farm.
“Over the next eight years, I learned very quickly that (interacting with) people is just as fun,” she says.
Today, her farm hosts a full farmers’ market alongside a farm-to-table cafe and U-pick options. Burnap’s Farm Market & Garden Cafe has also entered the agritainment business, providing recreational activities for kids and families. Burnap says it’s reduced her reliance on food processors by 70%.
While diversification has helped many farms, it’s not a simple matter. It requires careful planning, money, and time. Not everyone can do it successfully, and some farmers aren’t in a financial position to try.
The same is true of efficiency improvements. Adopting automation and other technology that drive the majority of output increases in farming is an expensive option.
“We’re trying to do a lot of things,” Kahlke says. “There’s automatic harvesters that have been trialed for years, there’s some in Washington, but they’re very expensive. Most farms wouldn’t be able to afford them here, and we’re still in the early stages of that automation.”
In the disaster designation request, Hochul urged communities to support farmers however they can, “by buying fresh local products from the farm or purchasing the many products made from New York fruit.”
It’s a message that resonates with area farmers.
“What I like to see every year is the fact that I become less dependent on, as I call it, the world market to buy my fruit,” Burnap says. “I become much more dependent on my local market, which is like a 200-mile radius to my business right now, to bag my food.”
For his part, Kahlke remains upbeat on the outlook for area farmers.
“We’re a small industry (in Western New York), but we’re well organized, and we have great people,” he says. “We’re in good shape if we plan.”
Brodie Martin is a Rochester Beacon contributing writer and a member of the Oasis Project’s third cohort.
The Beacon welcomes comments and letters from readers who adhere to our comment policy including use of their full, real name. See “Leave a Reply” below to discuss on this post. Comments of a general nature may be submitted to the Letters page by emailing [email protected].