|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
Canandaigua National Bank and Trust Co. was the only bidder Friday at a foreclosure auction for K2 Brothers Brewing’s former taproom on Empire Boulevard, taking the property with a $1,000 bid.
The auction at the Monroe County Hall of Justice in downtown Rochester lasted less than three minutes. The $1,000 bid matched the amount CNB bid in July for the former K2 brewery and taproom in Walworth. The bank is now set to take title to both properties.
Two men who appeared prepared to bid attended the auction. Before it began, they asked referee Eliza Gabrielle Heaton, who also handled the Walworth sale, whether she could disclose the minimum bid. She declined. They also asked how much bids would increase by.
A paralegal representing CNB through its law firm, Phillips Lytle, said bids would be made in $1 million increments.
“You said you’re going in increments of a million,” one of the men said.
“In a million,” Heaton replied.
The older man laughed.
“I don’t want it for a million,” he said.
Heaton then announced the $1,000 opening bid. CNB’s paralegal submitted the only bid, and the auction ended. The two men left shortly afterward (before I could talk with them). As the auction closed, the younger man estimated the property was worth about $600,000.
The $1,000 bid doesn’t establish what the property is worth or what it could sell for on the open market. A foreclosure auction can produce a result far from a property’s listing price or estimated value.
CNB has not commented on the auction or said what it plans to do with the property, despite multiple requests through its attorneys. A Phillips Lytle paralegal at the auction said she didn’t know what would happen next because that was outside her area of responsibility.
The 1221 Empire Blvd. property was originally listed for $1.1 million. That listing has since been removed, and no deed transfer had been recorded before Friday’s auction.
The property appeared to have a potential buyer over the summer. Tom Quigley and his son-in-law Phill MacArthur, a veteran local brewer, emerged in July as prospective buyers and floated reopening the space as a brewery and restaurant. They later dropped plans for second-floor renovations, the only part of the proposal that required town review, and Penfield determined no special use permit was needed.
MacArthur told me by text before the auction that the property had “many complexities” and that he viewed the auction as part of the process. He said that “if things work out,” he and Quigley would still look to buy it.
It’s unclear whether the two men at Friday’s auction were connected to MacArthur and Quigley. I believe they were, based on more than a decade covering the local beer scene, but I couldn’t confirm it. Any future purchase would now have to be negotiated with CNB.
K2 opened the Empire Boulevard brewery in late 2017. The brewery, restaurant and beer garden overlooking Irondequoit Bay became a destination for Rochester-area beer drinkers.
In 2023, K2 paid $1.45 million for the former Freewill Elementary School in Walworth, Wayne County, a 72,000-square-foot property on about 41 acres. It converted the gym into a brewery and the cafeteria into a taproom. K2 closed the Walworth operation in March 2025, citing rising costs and lower-than-expected sales. The company later faced claims from creditors, including Palmer Food Services, and New York state filed a tax warrant against the Empire Boulevard property.
CNB, which financed much of the expansion, sued to foreclose. A single judgment, entered March 30, covers both properties, which went to separate auctions. At the July 21 Walworth auction, CNB again submitted the only bid, $1,000. The referee’s statement put the total owed, with interest and fees, at more than $5.2 million. The foreclosure paperwork listed a $2.1 million upset price.
The sale doesn’t resolve what the Kennedys and their companies may still owe. When a property sells for less than the debt, the lender can ask a court for a deficiency judgment against the borrowers under Section 1371 of the state Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law. CNB has 90 days after the referee’s deed is delivered to ask. If it does, the court decides the property’s value on the sale date, not the bid, and that value determines how much of the gap remains. Given the size of the debt compared with CNB’s $1,000 bids, that question could matter a great deal here.
Hill Top Enterprises, a Wayne County paving company, has a $24,794.50 mechanic’s lien against 1221 Empire Blvd. that was likely to be wiped out by a completed sale. A separate foreclosure on the undeveloped lot at 1225 Empire Blvd., brought by EIE LLC over a $612,000 mortgage, remains pending and has been stayed since March, when Brad Kennedy filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy.
I’m also still waiting on a Freedom of Information Law request, filed Aug. 17, for Monroe County Industrial Development Corpo. records on loans to the Kennedys’ businesses. The county has said it expects to respond by Oct. 14.
Will Cleveland is a Rochester Beacon contributing writer. A former Democrat and Chronicle reporter, he writes about beer in the Finger Lakes region and Western New York on Substack.
The Beacon welcomes comments and letters from readers who adhere to our comment policy including use of their full, real name. See “Leave a Reply” below to discuss on this post. Comments of a general nature may be submitted to the Letters page by emailing [email protected].