|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
Workers at the George Eastman Museum voted 41-16 to unionize with Workers United, according to the organizing group, George Eastman Museum Workers United. The National Labor Relations Board election was held Friday, Oct. 2, and the group announced the result Sunday.
Seventy-five workers were eligible to vote, the group said. By its count, 57 votes were cast, a turnout of 76%. NLRB records list the museum as having about 100 employees. Supervisors, managers and other classifications were excluded from the voting groups.
Voting took place in the museum’s 7Crest Financial Partners Hall, 900 East Ave., from 9:30 to 11:30 a.m. and from 4 to 6 p.m., according to the NLRB’s official notice of election. Employees voted in two groups. Professional staff, including archivists, assistant curators, conservators and librarians, were first asked whether they wanted to be in the same bargaining unit as nonprofessional staff, such as part-time projectionists, box-office and restaurant workers, preparators and maintenance employees. Both groups then voted on whether to be represented by the Workers United Rochester Regional Joint Board. The union’s announcement did not break out the results by group.
Employees in seven job classifications whose eligibility was unresolved were allowed to vote challenged ballots, which are resolved after the election only if necessary. The NLRB’s online case page still listed the case as open Monday morning, with no official tally posted. Under NLRB procedures, either side can file objections within seven days of the vote count, and the results are not final until any objections are resolved. The union said it is not anticipating any objections among its members.
“Creating this union is such a major victory, not only for the George Eastman Museum staff, but the entire institution, local community, and the labor movement,” said Andrea Edwards, a preparator. “I cannot wait to see what more we can accomplish now that we are united as a union.”
Emily Phoenix, an assistant conservator, said the group now turns to bargaining a first contract.
“We look forward to working collaboratively with leadership towards our shared goals of making the museum the best place to work, visit, and learn that it can be,” she said.
She also credited outside support, including letters from unions and individuals, encouragement from elected officials and backing from participants in the museum’s Labor Film Series.
In response to questions the Beacon sent museum leadership Sunday afternoon, the museum said: “We respect the outcome of the union vote and look forward to working constructively with the union in the collective bargaining process. A timeline for that process will be determined.”
The responses were not attributed to a named official.
The museum added: “We appreciate our employees’ commitment to their work at the museum and their sincere desire to improve the museum for employees and others. Our focus will remain on supporting our staff and working together to fulfill the museum’s mission of preserving and sharing the art, history, technology, and science of photography and moving images and the legacy of George Eastman.”
The museum was founded in 1947 as an independent nonprofit on the former Rochester estate of Kodak founder George Eastman. It describes itself as the world’s oldest photography museum and one of the oldest film archives. The museum’s most recent federal tax filing, for 2024, reported 127 people employed during the year and about 99,800 visitors. The museum’s holdings include more than 400,000 photographs and 28,000 films.
The filing reported $14.3 million in revenue and $10.4 million in expenses. Contributions made up $7.8 million of the revenue, and investment income, including gains on sales, added $3.9 million. Salaries, benefits and payroll taxes totaled $5.7 million, about 55% of expenses. Net assets stood at $60.9 million, but $48.9 million of that was donor-restricted, including a $37.4 million permanent endowment. Net assets without donor restrictions were $12.1 million.

Workers first went public Friday, Aug. 28, delivering a letter to museum director Bruce Barnes and the board of trustees announcing their intent to unionize and asking for voluntary recognition. The Workers United Rochester Regional Joint Board filed for an NLRB election Aug. 31. At that time, Barnes said the museum was consulting attorneys. The letter cited concerns including transparency and consultation before policy changes, workloads matched to staffing, pay that keeps pace with the cost of living, workplace safety, freedom from harassment and protection from termination without just cause.
The museum did not voluntarily recognize the union. Asked why, it said: “The union did not provide the museum’s leadership with enough time or information for us to make an informed decision before filing the Petition for Election. In particular, the organizing employees did not provide us with information about how many employees had signed cards in favor of forming the union.”
The museum said that after the petition was filed, “we concluded that voluntarily recognizing the union would have deprived museum employees of their right to vote on whether the union should become their exclusive representative.”
It added: “A number of museum employees were not even aware of the organizing efforts. Proceeding with an NLRB election ensured that all eligible employees were able to have their voice heard on this important issue.”
NLRB records show a hearing in the case was rescheduled in early September and that the agency’s Buffalo regional office issued a decision directing an election Sept. 18. The union announced Sept. 22 that the vote would be held Oct. 2.
Once it was clear there would be an election, GEMWU says, nonsupervisory employees began receiving invitations to small meetings with a representative of Government Resources Consultants of America, a labor-relations consulting firm. The group said in an Instagram post that invitations arrived less than 30 minutes before the meetings.
“We see what’s happening with these closed meetings as union busting,” the group wrote.
In follow-up slides, it described tactics it told colleagues to watch for: “listening sessions,” appeals that the museum is a nonprofit that cannot afford raises, sudden offers to make long-requested changes, warnings about strikes and union rules, and attacks on the union itself. The group said consultants at the firm are reported to earn $200 an hour. The Beacon has not independently verified that figure. George Eastman Museum Workers United also reminded workers that federal labor law protects their right to organize and prohibits employers from retaliating against employees for engaging in protected organizing activity.
The museum disputed the union-busting characterization.
“The museum and its representatives strictly followed the rules of the National Labor Relations Board,” it said. “Our goal was to enable all of our employees to make free and informed choices of whether to vote ‘yes’ or ‘no’ on the formation of the proposed bargaining unit.”
The museum said it “retained a firm to conduct informational sessions for our employees, whose attendance at the meetings was entirely voluntary.”
It added: “We did not have the internal staff resources or the expertise to conduct these sessions in the few weeks between the union’s petition for election and the date on which employees would cast their vote about whether to form a union.”
The museum did not name the firm or say whether it is the one the union identified. It also did not say what it paid or whether it retained outside counsel. NLRB records list the law firm Nixon Peabody LLP as the museum’s legal representative in the case.
Employers are generally free to campaign against a union, within limits. The NLRB’s notice of election lists conduct that can lead the board to set aside an election, including threatening loss of jobs or benefits and promising raises or other benefits to influence a vote.
Government Resources Consultants of America is based in Grayslake, Ill. Under federal law, consultants hired to persuade employees about organizing, and the employers who hire them, generally must report those arrangements to the U.S. Department of Labor.
In filings for other clients, the firm has described its work as conducting employee and supervisory meetings to inform participants about their rights and responsibilities under the National Labor Relations Act, including secret-ballot elections, collective bargaining and union rules and finances. A search of the department’s online database found no employer report from the museum and no 2026 consultant report naming it. Such reports are not always posted promptly.
GEMWU confirmed that 75 workers were eligible to vote. It described the bargaining unit as “wall to wall,” meaning everyone who is nonsupervisory, and said it did not know the unit’s exact size. The union said it is still determining its bargaining priorities and has distributed a survey so staff can weigh in, with members to meet and set priorities based on that input. Asked about the main concerns that led workers to organize, it pointed to its Instagram account, which includes the workers’ initial letter, videos made for the election and testimonials about why workers were voting yes. The union did not say who will represent workers at the bargaining table after the vote.
Vivian Rivers, the museum’s community and volunteer liaison, explained her vote in a post.
“I care about my colleagues and the sustainability of working at GEM long-term,” she said.
The group has also been posting stark black-and-white portraits of its members, a fitting choice at a museum devoted to photography. Its logo, drawn by Edwards, is based on Lewis Hine’s 1920 photograph “Powerhouse Mechanic,” part of the Hine archive the museum has held since 1951.
GEMWU has said it will elect a bargaining committee from among its members, draft proposals based on the survey, and negotiate with museum leadership. Any contract would go to a ratification vote of all union members before taking effect.
Negotiations can take a long time. As the Beacon reported in August, workers at a Buffalo Starbucks became the first at a company-owned U.S. store to unionize, with Workers United, in December 2021. None of the unionized Starbucks stores had a ratified contract. Workers at the Chicago History Museum ratified their first contract in August. In Rochester, a union drive at the Strong National Museum of Play failed in 2025 by a vote of 53-63. Researchers who track organizing at private nonprofit art museums have found a 221% increase in union activity since 2019.
Workers United is headquartered at 750 East Ave., a few hundred feet from the museum at 900 East Ave. It also represents workers at the Sciencenter in Ithaca and the Buffalo AKG Art Museum.
Will Cleveland is a Rochester Beacon contributing writer. A former Democrat and Chronicle reporter, he writes about beer in the Finger Lakes region and Western New York on Substack.
The Beacon welcomes comments and letters from readers who adhere to our comment policy including use of their full, real name. See “Leave a Reply” below to discuss on this post. Comments of a general nature may be submitted to the Letters page by emailing [email protected].
Japan has now perfected mobile Museum Robot Workes with Immediate Interactive Security Response Geans. ONLY A MATTER OF TIME THESE “human” workers jobs will be HISTORY. Private or Pubmc, Nonprofit Organizations can ill-afford financial demands of unionized workers who put their own interests before a nonprofit community museum meant to benefit the educational & informative needs of said community. Unions misused in this way are antagonistic to the general publicist interests!
Unionized workers’ jobs will be historical because, unlike non-union workers, they can NEGOTIATE the use of AI technology in their workplace like they have for all types of technology for over eighty years. That information is part of the educational needs of our community that the GEM has provided for over three decades through its Dryden Theater.
This is wonderful news.
As the former Registrar of a small museum in Elmira, NY, I can say a union was needed there to address many issues regarding pay, work hours and the need for all staff to have some say in the operation of the museum.
Based on my experience, I believe the union will add much needed balance to a museum structure that is typically very lopsided. You have a museum director and a board of directors. These people are so far removed from the experiences and needs of the receptionist and maintenance staff. A union shifts the power structure and that’s a good thing.
Unionizing a non-profit Museum? Really? This is a long way from protecting kids from having to load rail cars in the depression for .75 cents a copy. For the employee’s sake, I hope they get better results than the mass layoffs and store closings the Union got at Starbucks.