Report calls for changes in child welfare system

Print More
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Twenty-one Monroe County women who have navigated the child welfare system say they needed support and dignity instead of facing a presumption of guilt.

“If there was a way to ask, ‘I need things for my home’ without being afraid of being judged, or to get the therapy my kids need without it turning around… It’s a huge level of shame and blame.” one mother said in a focus group.

Another said,  “It doesn’t matter if you’re actually innocent of it. It’s, ‘We’re going to make you guilty no matter what.’”

These accounts anchor a new report, “Voices of Experience: Findings from Focus Groups with Women Impacted by the Child Welfare System,” published by HOPE585, a nonprofit that works with and advocates for families and youth in foster care. 

Across four trauma-informed focus groups, the women described avoiding schools, doctors, therapists and community agencies for fear that asking for help would bring a Child Protective Services investigation or family separation. Researchers conducted these groups in March and April.

“There’s this huge misconception that every family that is involved with the child welfare system has done something wrong, and we really want to retell that story,” says Ashley Cross, executive director of HOPE585 and co-author of the report. “Many of these families have, in fact, not done anything wrong. They’re just navigating poverty.”

Exposure to the child welfare system can be harmful for children and families when it is not necessary, she adds.

“There’s this knee-jerk reaction sometimes to just call CPS,” Cross says.

Data show that Monroe County CPS received 6,434 reports of suspected child abuse or neglect in 2025, or 43 for every 1,000 children. Of the reports determined as of March 20, about 75% were unfounded. Black children were 5.5 times more likely and Hispanic children 3.5 times more likely to enter foster care than white children, according to county data.

Cross says mandated reporters, who are required by state law to report suspected child abuse or maltreatment, have little room to use judgment. The first issue, she says, is legislation that “doesn’t allow for professionals to respond in different ways.”

“People really do think that CPS is coming to help families, and they don’t realize that they’re coming to investigate them,” Cross says. “That’s why it’s called an investigation.”

Brandy Shaw, co-author of the report and HOPE585’s manager of advocacy and policy, says the definition of child neglect tends to be a catch-all category. The statutory framework is broad to cover all forms of neglect—physical, mental or emotional.

“When we say knee-jerk reaction, we’re not talking about people that see bruises or something that’s very evident that there needs to be an intervention,” Shaw says. “We are talking about things like … a student coming to school with the same clothes on, or then you have cultural differences.”

Read : When a cry for help becomes a call to CPS

If providers could check whether resources, including cash, could alleviate a situation, Cross and Shaw say, then CPS would not be necessary. Participants said unmet needs such as housing, mental health care and child care were sometimes read as neglect rather than a call for help. Some said an investigation followed when they reached out. “I’m scared to bring them to doctors, school, anywhere,” one participant said in a focus group. 

Others said schools and service providers weren’t equipped to support children with autism or complex behavioral needs, and that those struggles sometimes escalated into child welfare cases.

Fear of system involvement kept families from seeking support in times of need, with isolation intensifying following child welfare involvement, the report states.

Participants also said they got little information about their rights, and described lasting effects including hypervigilance, shame and fear of future separation from their children.

Cross says the women were not asking for less accountability. They were asking for support and dignity. She hopes policymakers, service providers, and community leaders will learn from these findings and work with parents to advance reforms. Shaw believes a parent advisory board, drawing on insight from parents impacted by the system, could go a long way toward solutions.

The report lists four recommendations drawn from the focus groups:

■ shift from surveillance-based intervention to community-based prevention and family support;

■ incorporate lived experience leadership into child welfare systems;

■ increase transparency and accountability; and

■ invest in trauma-informed practices across systems.

Cross likens this to the efforts made in public safety following the deaths of George Floyd and Daniel Prude in police custody. In Rochester, the Person in Crisis team has trained social workers, mental health counselors and others to assess and divert behavioral health situations from punitive police intervention.

“There was a level of compassion and empathy that people had for those men who really needed mental health professional support,” Cross says. “Women and families impacted by child welfare are in very similar situations many times. We just don’t see the harm.”

She places priority on shifting supports as far upstream as possible. 

In a legislative brief, HOPE585 says the state should advance Parental Rights Notification Legislation, or Family Miranda. The proposed legislation calls for verbal and written rights information at the initial point of contact.

The brief ends with several next steps that include investing in community support, advancing legislation that makes support more accessible and funding parent advocacy.

Cross says transparency and accountability are a huge priority for her, and that many of the women understood investigators had a job to do.

“They weren’t upset that they were investigated,” she says. “They were upset that they were disrespected and that they had dehumanizing experiences with government officials, and that they had no one to talk to about it.”

Smriti Jacob is Rochester Beacon managing editor.

The Beacon welcomes comments and letters from readers who adhere to our comment policy including use of their full, real name. See “Leave a Reply” below to discuss on this post. Comments of a general nature may be submitted to the Letters page by emailing [email protected].

One thought on “Report calls for changes in child welfare system”

  1. This article and the companion article from HOPE585 demand that we all check ourselves on such important issues as adequate support for children and families. It is the humane and cost-effective thing to do. Time in prison and the inability to work without supports for childcare and health care are much more costly to society and taxpayers. Budget cuts and scarce resources often seem to require negative action instead of positive action. We will spend many times the resources treating many people as possibly undeserving in order to save a dollar on just one possibly scamming the system. The goal must always be about children and supporting families/caregivers. I care not about the political views of families as undeserving or deserving.
    It must always be about the children first. None of us get to pick our birth circumstances, not the color of our skin, who our parents are, or what money there is for a decent start and an education. Some of the problems here are part of human nature that we are all part of, including myself. Convinced one person is underserving, then there must be many more. Getting scammed by on bogus charity and we deny help to all groups that help our neighbors because they could be dishonest too. Being as humane as we can be and demanding it of who we elect to administer our society, is what civilization meant in a modern world. We can do better.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *