|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
The first time Child Protective Services knocked on my door, my oldest child was only six months old.
I had barely slept. My baby had cried for hours the night before. I fed him, changed him, rocked him, and walked the floor until my body ached. Nothing worked. Eventually, overcome by exhaustion, I let him cry so I could get some rest.

I was a young, single mother trying to survive without the support of a village. Every day brought another worry. How would I pay the bills? How would I keep food in the house? How could I be the mother my child deserved when I was barely holding myself together?
The next morning, CPS was at my door. Someone had reported me because my baby had been crying for too long. I remember the fear and shame. Who called them? Were they going to take my baby? Had being an exhausted mother somehow made me an unfit one?
I needed someone to recognize that I was struggling. Instead, someone decided I needed to be investigated. And once that happens, something changes. You begin to wonder who is watching, who is judging, and who might make the next call. The people around you no longer feel like a community you can depend on. They become people you are afraid to trust.
Unfortunately, that was not my last encounter with CPS. During a separate investigation, two of my children were removed because of concerns about the condition of my home. For two days, I was separated from them. After I cleaned my home, they were returned.
I understood that my children deserved a safe home. But I also needed help addressing the concerns, not the experience of having my children taken away. Those two days reinforced something I had already begun to believe: When you are a struggling parent, asking for help or admitting that things are not okay can come with devastating consequences.
I needed a village. Instead, I learned to fear the people who were supposed to be part of it.
My experience is not unique. In March and April, HOPE585 conducted four focus groups with 21 women across Monroe County who had experienced involvement with the child welfare system. A troubling pattern emerged from their stories. Women described struggling with housing, child care, mental health concerns, and their children’s behavioral challenges, only to encounter investigation, judgment, or the threat of family separation.

One mother had escaped violence at home and found full-time employment. But without child care, she had to turn down the job. Her circumstances deteriorated, eventually contributing to a CPS report. “If I would’ve had child care,” she told HOPE585, “I would’ve been all right, because I would’ve been able to rebuild.”
Another mother described being reported because multiple children shared a bedroom. She knew her family needed more space but could not afford to move. Her frustration was not simply that someone recognized a problem. It was that no one offered a solution. “Offer something,” she pleaded.
These women were not asking anyone to ignore their children’s needs. They were asking why their struggles were treated as evidence of parental failure rather than opportunities for support. But perhaps the most troubling finding was what happened after families became involved with CPS: They stopped trusting the people and institutions they once believed were there to help them.
One mother described becoming homeless with her children and seeking assistance from a local nonprofit organization. Instead of receiving the help she hoped for, she became the subject of a CPS investigation. Another sought professional guidance after noticing concerning behaviors in her young children. She described how her attempts to find help resulted in repeated investigations.
For these mothers, the lesson was clear: Asking for help could put their families at risk. “If you reach out, someone’s going to judge you and report you,” one woman explained. Another said, “I’m scared to bring them to doctors, school, anywhere.”
Consider what those words mean. A mother afraid to take her child to the doctor. A parent hesitant to tell a teacher something is wrong. A caregiver reluctant to seek counseling because acknowledging a struggle might invite an investigation.
Children depend on relationships with teachers, doctors, neighbors, extended family, and community organizations. Those relationships are supposed to create a network of protection around them. But when parents begin to associate those relationships with the possibility of being reported, that network can unravel.
A teacher who might have been a trusted partner becomes someone a parent fears confiding in. A neighbor who could provide relief becomes someone whose intentions are questioned. And the next time a family faces a crisis, they may choose silence over seeking help.
One woman described what could have made a difference: “If there was a way to ask, ‘I need things for my home’ without being afraid of being judged, or to get the therapy my kids need without it turning around. … It’s a huge level of shame and blame.”
The consequences can last long after an investigation ends. During the HOPE585 focus groups, women described years of anxiety, isolation, and distrust. Some became visibly emotional recounting experiences from years earlier. “I was in fight or flight mode all the time,” one mother recalled.
In Monroe County, 75% of CPS investigations are closed without a finding of child maltreatment. That does not mean every report was inappropriate. Child abuse and neglect are real, and professionals must act when there is reasonable suspicion that a child is being harmed. But we must ask whether our approach to protecting children sometimes damages the very relationships that help keep them safe.
The women HOPE585 interviewed were clear about what they needed: child care, housing assistance, mental health services, support for their children, professionals who listened, and safe places to ask for help without fear.
“There has to be a place where you can ask for help without it being used against you,” one woman said.
We agree. We need mandated reporters who can distinguish reasonable suspicion of maltreatment from circumstances calling for practical support. We need trusted, community-based organizations where families can voluntarily seek assistance before a crisis escalates. And we need parents with lived experience helping shape the policies and practices that affect their families.
Twenty-one years after that first knock on the door, Naishah still remembers what it felt like to be an exhausted mother whose need for support was met with investigation. After listening to 20 other women, it’s clear that fear is not hers alone.
When we respond to struggling families with suspicion instead of support, we risk breaking the very relationships that help keep children safe. A community where parents are afraid to ask for help is not a safer community. It is a more isolated one.
The next time a parent is struggling, we should not only ask whether a child is safe. We should also ask what that family needs to remain safe, supported, and together.
Naishah Brown-Ebanks is a lived-experience expert, advocate, facilitator, and mother who draws from her experiences in the child welfare systems and mental health, to advocate for meaningful policy and systems change.
Ashley Cross, Ed.D., is founder and executive director of HOPE585, a nonprofit dedicated to empowering marginalized youth and families. A third-generation foster parent and advocate for policy change, she has spent her career building hope-centered communities.
The Beacon welcomes comments and letters from readers who adhere to our comment policy including use of their full, real name. See “Leave a Reply” below to discuss on this post. Comments of a general nature may be submitted to the Letters page by emailing [email protected].
Unfortunately, this fits in with today’s stories about school absenteeism.
Being absent from school has many causes and should usually be seen as a cry for help rather than blaming the victim.