|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|

This story is a joint publication partnership between the Rochester Beacon and the Cleveland Prost.
In Norse mythology, beer was magic. Zeb Zimmerman told me so in the spring of 2019, a few days after he and his wife, Emily, opened Nine Maidens Brewing on University Avenue, while he poured me a pint of his hoppy amber ale. He was 28, it was Monroe County’s smallest brewery, and the couple didn’t have kids yet.
More than seven years later, Nine Maidens is closing. The brewery will pour its last pints Nov. 14 and host a final party for Mug Club members Nov. 15. Its lease at 1344 University Ave. runs out Nov. 30, and the Zimmermans have decided not to sign another.
The writing on the wall
Zeb Zimmerman, now 36, says the decision had been coming for a while. With the lease ending, they had to choose whether to keep going, and he didn’t like what he saw over the next couple of years.
“It’s the right time, honestly,” he says. “Ultimately, it just feels like good timing. We had to make the decision of whether we continued or stopped on Nov. 30. Right now, we can see the writing on the wall for the next year or two. I don’t want to sign a contract promising a landlord that I’ll be able to pay for another year or two. It’s easier to do it now and keep both sides happy and not get into a bad situation.”

In their announcement, the Zimmermans cited a shift in consumer habits, the rising cost of doing business and the rising cost of living. Zeb Zimmerman is careful about how that gets read, though, and he doesn’t want the closing taken as a verdict on Rochester’s craft beer scene.
“I don’t want this to be an indictment on the industry,” he says. “If anything, it’s an indictment on my business model. It’s hard to make ends meet with a small system, but especially with the rising cost of living. If you own a business, your goal is to give yourself a raise every year. But it’s just impossible to keep up with the cost of living and the cost of doing business and the cost of rent and everything going on at the same time.”
One barrel at a time
The small system was the whole idea at the start. Zeb Zimmerman left a full-time job at a law firm to open Nine Maidens, and since he couldn’t afford a 10-barrel system, he built a one-barrel setup himself, buying parts with each paycheck over 18 months and assembling it at home. He drew the taproom schematics at 2:45 a.m. in Mumbai, where he’d gone for a friend’s wedding right after signing the lease, then came home and did most of the construction on his own. Emily Zimmerman, a graphic designer, gave the brewery its look, down to the nine maidens tucked into the logo, and artist Ryan Martin painted the north wall with a mural of the nine daughters of Aegir, the Norse god said to brew the best beer.
Brewing 31 gallons at a time meant the tap list never sat still. Zeb Zimmerman estimates they made more than 100 different beers and seltzers over the years, and they eventually upgraded to a two-barrel system while keeping the rotating lineup. Looking back, he says, that was fun but too much work for too little revenue, and he now thinks they should have built bigger from the start.
“I think that was our strength when we started and I think that became one of our detriments,” he says. “Now people aren’t looking for a rotating tap list, they’re looking for flagships and consistency. It’s strange how many people come in and they go, ‘Well, I was here two years ago and I had this beer I really liked.’ And I’m like, ‘Well, sorry, that beer kicked in three weeks.’”
Life changes, plans change

Their daughter Leona was born two months after the brewery opened, and her sister, Izzy, is now 19 months old. When the Zimmermans sat down with a pros-and-cons list this year, the girls weighed heavily on the side of closing.
“A huge weight on the side of closing was my family, especially my youngest daughter Izzy,” Zeb Zimmerman says. “I’d rather have nights and weekends with her.”
Leona, meanwhile, has spent her whole life around the taproom.
“She’s grown up with this brewery,” he says. “It’s been cool. It has made her really outgoing. She’s a people person, for sure because of it.”
The news gave me an excuse to dig my 2019 story out of the archives, and it’s hard to read it now without thinking about how much has changed. Zeb Zimmerman and I both have two kids now, and my 5-year-old played T-ball with Leona this year. We lived through a pandemic, which Nine Maidens survived with canning sessions when nobody could sit at the bar, and through whatever the heck is going on right now. Life changes, plans change, and you really can’t predict this stuff.
What’s next
Zeb Zimmerman has been interviewing for a while and expects to head back into the corporate world, likely in marketing. He doesn’t sound like a man with regrets. He says he jumps into everything 100%, and Nine Maidens was his dream before he had kids. These days he thinks more about being home and about financial security, and, he adds with a chuckle, he has less energy at 36 than he did at 28.
“The summation is really this is what I wanted at the time and I enjoyed it supremely,” he says. “I loved doing it. I met so many cool people. I know that half the brewers in town will be my friends for life and half of my customers will be friends for life.”
The Zimmermans’ announcement thanked the Mug Club members, regulars, friends, family and bartenders who filled the place for seven years of Bills games, trivia nights, collaborations and late nights, and it sent people off to Rochester’s other craft breweries, where they hope to share a pint again. It’s a generous send-off and good advice besides.
Get to University Avenue by Nov. 14, order the hoppy amber if it’s on and thank whoever’s behind the bar, then keep showing up at the small places that remain.
Not many people can say they chased a dream and gave it everything they had, and fewer still get to step away on their own terms, honest about why and with their friendships intact. Rochester’s beer scene will be a little smaller without Nine Maidens.
Will Cleveland is a Rochester Beacon contributing writer. A former Democrat and Chronicle reporter, he writes about beer in the Finger Lakes region and Western New York on Substack.
The Beacon welcomes comments and letters from readers who adhere to our comment policy including use of their full, real name. See “Leave a Reply” below to discuss on this post. Comments of a general nature may be submitted to the Letters page by emailing [email protected].
“ But it’s just impossible to keep up with the cost of living and the cost of doing business and the cost of rent and everything going on at the same time.”
Another way to put it is “elections have consequences.”
Please vote conscientiously.