County set to pay $537,500 to autistic man punched by jail deputy

Print More
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Monroe County would pay $537,500 to settle a lawsuit filed by a man with autism who was beaten by a sheriff’s deputy inside the county jail, an attack a federal judge called “gratuitous and unreasonable.”

Deputy Brett Kirkpatrick threw the punches while a second deputy held Richard Dzionara-Norsen against a wall with one arm pinned behind his back, according to the judge’s review of jail surveillance video. Kirkpatrick and an official testifying on the county’s behalf later admitted under oath that the punches were excessive.

Kirkpatrick was suspended for 20 days. He still works at the jail and was paid $98,526 in 2026, according to county payroll data posted on SeeThroughNY. Dzionara-Norsen was being held in the jail at the time awaiting sentencing; a federal jury had convicted him days earlier of possessing, receiving and distributing child pornography. He was later sentenced to six years in federal prison.

Photo by Will Cleveland

The harm didn’t end that day, according to his lawyer, Elliot Shields: The jail never got him to the surgery he needed to set his broken nose, and it healed crooked.

The Monroe County Legislature’s Ways and Means Committee is scheduled to vote on the settlement Dec. 3, and the full Legislature is set to take it up Dec. 8. County Executive Adam Bello, who sent the deal to legislators Nov. 6, asked that they discuss it behind closed doors. The money would come from the county’s Risk Management Fund.

The amount includes legal fees and costs and resolves every claim against the county, Sheriff Todd Baxter and both deputies, Shields said. It includes no admission of liability and no changes to jail policy or training, he said, but it leaves in place a July 2025 ruling by U.S. District Judge Meredith Vacca that Kirkpatrick used excessive force and was not shielded by qualified immunity.

Dzionara-Norsen, then 29, was being held under constant supervision in the jail’s reception annex on the afternoon of Nov. 25, 2020, the day before Thanksgiving.

According to Vacca’s ruling, which relied heavily on jail surveillance video, Kirkpatrick let Dzionara-Norsen out of his cell about 3:54 p.m. so he could speak with mental health staff. Dzionara-Norsen told deputies he would not go back to his cell until he could call his mother, and the deputies said he swore at them. When he kept walking toward the mental health area, Deputy David Gertin grabbed his wrist, pinned his right arm behind his back and pushed him against a wall.

Within about a second, the ruling states, Kirkpatrick ran over and punched Dzionara-Norsen in the head, then three more times in rapid succession, knocking the left side of his head into the edge of an open metal door. Both of his shoes came off. The judge wrote that Dzionara-Norsen never fought back and had no way to shield his face.

Court records list Dzionara-Norsen at 5 feet 9 inches and about 140 pounds, Gertin at about 220 pounds and Kirkpatrick at about 200. Dzionara-Norsen was taken to Strong Memorial Hospital and treated for facial fractures. He was discharged with instructions to follow up for surgery to repair his nose, but the operation never happened, Shields said, citing medical records as summarized by the plaintiff’s facial plastic surgery expert.

A Dec. 3, 2020, surgery date was canceled over a COVID-19 testing requirement. A second date fell through because the jail and the hospital didn’t coordinate, Shields said. After Dzionara-Norsen then contracted COVID-19, the surgery was postponed indefinitely and never done. According to the expert, such a fracture has to be set within two to three weeks; because his wasn’t, the bones healed crooked, and he will need reconstructive surgery on his nose and septum to correct it.

“There is no other way to describe Kirkpatrick’s use of force in this case except as gratuitous and unreasonable,” Vacca wrote.

Kirkpatrick’s supervisor reviewed the video and immediately pulled him from duty with inmates after concluding he had used unreasonable force, according to the ruling. An Internal Affairs investigation reached the same conclusion, and Baxter suspended Kirkpatrick for 20 days and ordered additional training. Gertin also still works at the jail and was paid $117,032 in 2026, according to the same payroll data.

An official testifying under oath on the county’s behalf admitted that punching Dzionara-Norsen in the face four times was “unreasonable and unnecessary,” and Kirkpatrick admitted that “all four punches were unreasonable and excessive,” the judge wrote.

The lawsuit, filed in November 2021, alleged that Kirkpatrick was allowed to use banked vacation or sick time to cover the suspension, and that the jail then disciplined Dzionara-Norsen himself, finding him guilty of being “disrespectful to authority” at what the complaint called a “sham” hearing and sentencing him to 20 days in solitary confinement and a $25 fine.

The suit also accused the county of disability discrimination, arguing that deputies mistook behavior common in people with autism for defiance, and said Baxter failed to train deputies to deal with people like Dzionara-Norsen. The county denied the allegations.

The case went through years of failed mediation, including two settlement conferences this summer, before the deal was reached.

Dzionara-Norsen, now 35, has been out of federal Bureau of Prisons custody since Nov. 28, 2025, according to the bureau’s inmate locator. He was locked up again this year after federal probation officials accused him of violating the terms of his supervised release, and a detention order was issued, according to a May order in a separate federal case he filed.

He was held in the Livingston County Jail this spring but is now out of custody and living at home, Shields said. He declined to comment on the criminal case. Dzionara-Norsen is listed on the state sex offender registry as a Level 2 offender living in Rochester, and he remains under federal supervision, which the registry lists as running through 2034.

In June, U.S. District Judge Frank Geraci Jr., who presided over his trial, rejected his bid to have his convictions thrown out.

Dzionara-Norsen is represented by Shields, of Roth & Roth, and Donald Thompson of Easton Thompson Kasperek Shiffrin.

“This settlement compensates Richard for what was done to him, and nothing in it walks back that ruling,” Shields said. “Richard is autistic, he posed no threat that could justify being punched in the face four times, and he still lives with the injuries from that day.”

Monroe County did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the settlement or on Shields’ account of the canceled surgery.

The Legislature has approved other large settlements recently, including $500,000 in May to blinded Rochester police Officer Denny Wright and $360,000 in 2024 to the family of Sitarah Daniels, who died by suicide in the county jail.

­Will Cleveland is a Rochester Beacon contributing writer and a former Democrat and Chronicle reporter. He writes about beer in the Finger Lakes region and Western New York at Cleveland Prost and publishes investigative pieces at The Genesee Signal.

The Beacon welcomes comments and letters from readers who adhere to our comment policy including use of their full, real name. See “Leave a Reply” below to discuss on this post. Comments of a general nature may be submitted to the Letters page by emailing [email protected].

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *